James Davis Walker: With Friends Like These | Ep 20

James Davis Walker was a 53 year old living in Thaxton, VA. He loved woodworking and fishing, and had 7 children. On April 7, 2000, James allegedly went with some friends to the Food Lion in Bedford, VA. He waited outside while his friends went inside. When they came back out, he was gone. He was never seen again.

Rebecca Gary: The Perils of Popularity | Ep 19

Becky Pauline Gary was a 32 year old single mother living in Baton Rouge, LA. She liked making friends at local coffee shops and hobnobbing with the city’s upper class. On Dec. 27th, 1988, she called her sister, telling her things weren’t working out in Baton Rouge and that she was ready to move to Shreveport. Becky was never seen again.

Stephanie Hartwell: The Art Of The Lure | Ep 236

Stephanie Dianne Hartwell was a 25 year old from Columbia, MS. She was the mother of four, including twin boys. On the morning of November 28, 2001, Stephanie told her neighbor that she was headed to the store and would be right back. She then got into the car of a woman she knew. Stephanie never returned. She was never seen again.

Skyler Burnley: The Lost Day | Ep 233

Joseph Skyler Burnley, Sky to those who knew him best, was a 27 year old from Florence, MS. He was a natural athlete who was very close to his brother and sister. On June 3, 2016, Sky, a friend, and the friend’s girlfriend went to look for the friend’s truck that had been stolen. The two men went into the woods. The friend came back. Sky did not. He was never seen again.

Jake Latiolais: The Public’s Evidence | 232

Jake Allen Latiolais was a 22 year old from Brtusly, LA. He was a father who loved fishing. On Aug. 27, 2014, Jake had dinner with his grandmother and brother. After this, there are no substantiated sightings of Jake. But his truck was found on a bridge overlooking the Mississippi River in the early hours of Aug. 29—over 24 hours later. He was never seen again.

Benjamin Archer: Vision Quest | 231


Benjamin Morse Archer was a 32 year old from Delaware City, DE. He was very artistic and had survived a serious car wreck. At approximately 6am on March 2, 2016, Ben walked away from his mother’s home. He was found a few hour later in a local park, bare foot and shivering. When his family returned later, Ben wasn’t there. He was never seen again.

Patricia Marie Dudek: Out of Place | 230

Patricia Marie Dudek was a 33 year old from Salisbury, MD. She was the mother of 3 and had recently moved in with her boyfriend. On the morning of January 7, 2002, Patty’s daughter left for school while her mother and the boyfriend were arguing. When the daughter came home, Patty wasn’t there. She was never seen again.